Monday, 2010-06-21, around 23:00 Teon server time (UTC+2), Silent Valley
So me (a level 79 Maestro) in Nightmare Heavy and with my trusty Basalt Battlehammer went to grind a bit in Silent Valley. I took our "little" 73 Bounty Hunter Amerleen (in shiney A-grade equipment) and our 78 Dominator Fluff (in Major Arcana robes and with an Arcana Mace) with me, since both are so seldom online when I am and I wanted to get them a bit of XP too.
Arriving at the deep end of the valley, we noticed a bunch of dead bodies lying around - most likely bots (people don't tend to waste time lying dead so long). Along comes DelianZ, an untagged Wind Rider in S80 equipment and thus easily outmatching every single one of us, with a nice red PKer name. Oh well, if he feels like PKing bots, or even other people, I don't mind. His and their problem. So we let him go ... until he attacked Fluff, at which point he dies. "Sorry, man." I PM him. "NP, I'll be back." he PMs back.
So I warn my party and we go on merrily slaughtering mobs left and right when I see him, still red, back on the horizon. He washes away his karma killing more mobs and comes back to us, attacking us again. So we start giving him a handful of Dwarven love right in his face. He uses Hide, then drops my golem and lands a lucky blow on Fluff, killing him, at which point it's just me with a bit of help from Amerleen against him.
He dies. Again.
I resurrect Fluff and we get ready to kill more mobs as a bunch of RedSky guys comes along and drops me for being flagged (way to make friends for your struggling alliance, scrubs!), ao I got back to the clan hall and restock on GCP pots. So I'm not there when Amerleen gets killed by DelianZ (yay, he managed to kill an A-grade Bounty Hunter, what a hero ...). Too bad, he'd probably just die a third time ...
End result: An S80 dagger goes in an area which he already outlevelled some time ago, attacks people a grade or two under his gear level, and only manages to get an "even". Way to fail.